| The
name 'Maurelii' derives from Musa sp. var. Maureli D. Bois. Bois
named the plant in commemoration of J. Maurel who first drew to the attention of the
French authorities in Ethiopia the red-leaved "bananas" of that place. Moore
1957 describes this plant under the name "Musa Maurelii" which
may have been interpreted by some as raising it to species status. However, this was
not Moore's intention and he states specifically that the binomial "Musa Maurelii"
has no proper botanical standing under the International Code of Botanical Nomenclature.
Some
nurserymen do however regard 'Maurelii' as a distinct species of Musa or Ensete
and it is interesting to note that Bois himself was rather unsure as to what the plant
before him actually was. In his 1930 paper, Bois named two "red-leaved
bananas". The first plant he readily recognised as a form of Musa ensete
that he named var. Montbeliardi, which, formalised by Cufodontis 1972, is now
understood to be a form of Ensete ventricosum. The second plant was so
different in habit to the first that Bois doubted that it was Musa ensete but
instead a form of an unknown Musa.
Although
Bois was not able precisely to identify the second plant it is possible from the context
of the "discovery" of the plants by Maurel and from Bois' paper to deduce i)
that both
plants are Ensete ventricosum (it is now known that there are no African Musa
and no other species of Ensete occurs in Ethiopia) and ii) that both
are cultivated varieties (cultivars) and not naturally occuring varieties growing and
reproducing themselves in the "wild".
The
physical difference between 'Maurelii' and 'Montbeliardii' is indeed striking, 'Maurelii'
short and squat, 'Montbeliardii' tall and elegant, (see Graf for photographs) but this
simply reflects the polymorphic nature of Ensete ventricosum. That the
plants are cultivated forms and not wild forms means that the names given by Bois should
properly have cultivar status and be written e.g. 'Maurelii' and not maurelii.
Finally, to accord with modern practise under the International Code of Nomenclature of
Cultivated Plants, cultivar names commemorating a person should (in this case) end in
"ii".
Both 'Maurelii' and 'Montbeliardii' were introduced into the U.S.A. by David Barry Jr. and
released through his California Jungle Gardens in Los Angeles. Although 'Maurelii'
is still widely available in the U. S. and Europe I (drc) have been quite unable to locate
a plant of 'Montbeliardii'.
'Maurelii'
is sometimes offered commercially as 'Atropurpureum' or 'Rubra' or 'Rubrum' but these are
invalid names. Further, there is no discernible difference in the plants on
different U.K. nurseries to warrant such a distinction. Any differences reported are
due only to cultivation conditions that can have quite profound effects on plant colour
and morphology.
Images:
There are 3 images of Ensete ventricosum 'Maurelii' and links to 2 external
images. |