| Comments |
The
information in Baker's and Cheesman's papers cannot be reconciled but I have not yet seen
Kurz's paper to be certain who is right (probably Cheesman is). In his discussion of Musa acuminata Colla (for which
he gives M. simiarum Rumph. as a synonym) Baker writes that, compared with
typical M. acuminata "Var. culta, Kurz, is larger in all its parts, with much larger
whitish or yellowish flowers and longer cylindrical or angled yellow or greenish fruits". In contrast, Cheesman writes that "Kurz [ ] used
the name "M. simiarum Rumph." to cover an assemblage of wild and
cultivated, seeded and seedless forms. He distinguished four varieties, a. sylvestris,
b. violacea, c. culta and d. corniculata, and to the first he
added as a synonym M. acuminata Colla....".
Cheesman includes Kurz's a. sylvestris and b. violacea
varieties of M. simiarum Rumph. as synonyms of M. acuminata Colla but
excludes c. culta and d. corniculata. |