veryard projects - innovation for demanding change


veryard projects > business organization management > bureaucracy
we offer definition on this page links

management briefings and technical education

independent advice on tools and methods

Bureaucracy refers to a particular form and style of administrative organization.

Although it has been subject to strong criticism for a long time, bureaucracy and its variants can still be found in a large number of organizations.






sources of material


notion finder

contact us

veryard projects - innovation for demanding change

Views on Bureaucracy

veryard projects > business organization management > bureaucracy > views

Weber Described an ideal type of bureaucractic organization, which he equated with administrative rationality.
Merton Bureaucracy becomes inflexible because of various unanticipated consequences that derive from its structure.
Crozier Bureaucracies embody vicious circles of decreasing efficiency and effectiveness.
Jaques Described an ideal type of hierarchical organization.
See Penguin Dictionary of Sociology, under Bureaucracy.

veryard projects - innovation for demanding change

Pitfalls of Bureaucracy

veryard projects > business organization management > bureaucracy > pitfalls

There is a tendency in some bureaucratic organizations to regard small disasters as equally bad as large disasters, if not worse (because a large disaster is regarded as Act of God, whereas a small disaster is the fault of an individual). Therefore trivial risks must be avoided at all costs, even if it means incurring huge risks. more
A bureaucrat suffers from a particularly virulent strain of the multiplication fallacy. Each step of formalization can be individually justified, therefore all formalization can be justified. If it is good to measure this or that aspect of performance, then he ends up measuring all aspects of performance, because he cannot bear to forego any one.

veryard projects - innovation for demanding change

Alternatives to Bureaucracy

veryard projects > business organization management > bureaucracy > alternatives

Traditional Authority (Weber)
Market, Network, Clan
Adhocracy (Mintzberg)
Learning Organization
Participative / Democratic

veryard projects - innovation for demanding change

Misconceptions about Bureaucracy

veryard projects > business organization management > bureaucracy > misconceptions

Some of these misconceptions were found in student essays.

Bureaucracy equals corruption

Associating bureaucracy with unaccountable power, corruption, favouritism, and other unattractive characteristics. Criticizing bureaucracy for these characteristics.

One of Weber’s main arguments was that a good bureaucracy removed or reduced opportunities for corruption, favouritism and arbitrary exercises of power, which were characteristic of previous organizational forms. Bureaucracy may concentrate power (at the top), but also provides for checks and balances to prevent the abuse of power.

While some so-called bureaucracies may still manifest various undesirable characteristics to some extent, this is arguably not because they are bureaucratic, but because they aren’t bureaucratic enough.

Sometimes extra paperwork is added to a system to make corruption or favouritism more difficult. This almost certainly makes the system less efficient, but is supposed to make it more equitable.  Bribery or nepotism should stand out, because they do not conform to the approved procedures.

Sometimes bureaucracy fails to eliminate these practices, or even amplifies them. (Perhaps instead of bribing a single official, you now have to bribe several officials.)

This suggests a more accurate and sophisticated criticism of bureaucracy – that its attempts to deal with unethical, inefficient or other bad practices are counter-productive, actually making things worse rather than better. Bureaucracy isn’t itself corrupt, but it is ineffective in dealing with corruption.

Bureaucracy equals inefficiency and incompetence

People sometimes equate bureaucracy with any manifestation of administrative incompetence. (Several of our students cited the same anecdote, of a man whose bank failed to properly update its records of his address.) But true bureaucracy, for all its faults, is meticulous, almost obsessive about accurate record-keeping.

Obviously error can creep into bureaucratic systems as well as any other system. Bureaucracy is then characterized not by the presence of error, but by the sometimes absurd ways that the system tries to eliminate error.

"A French businesswoman was recently summoned to the Prefecture because - as the official letter of invitation claimed - she had lost her carte vitale (the French health smart card).  In fact, she had not lost it; so when, after waiting for over two hours, she got to the front of the queue and produced her card as proof that she had not lost it, the bureaucrat who was dealing with her said: 'But the computer says you have lost is, so the one you have now is no longer valid - you'll have to hand it in to be destroyed, and then ask for a new one!'  If there was ever such a thing as an ethic of bureaucracy, this is an example of it." [Slavoj Zizek, Revolution at the Gates (Verso 2002) p 185].

Bureaucracy equals size

Some students identified bureaucracy with any large organization. Microsoft and Enron were both identified as bureaucratic. While it is probably true that any large organization has some elements of bureaucracy, these two are unlikely examples of typical bureaucratic organizations, and their strengths and weaknesses are not obviously caused by the presence of bureaucracy. It is more likely to be the other way around – their strengths and weaknesses are associated with the fact that they have less bureaucracy than their competitors.

Bureaucracy equals perfect administrative rationality

Of course, this was Max Weber's view, but it is now largely discredited.  Students who adopt Weber’s view uncritically are in danger of overlooking a very large body of work – both on the nature of organizations and on the nature of rationality. We would be extremely impressed by a student who carefully considered this later work, and articulated cogent arguments against it. We are not impressed by students who simply ignore such considerations.

Bureaucracy equals something else

Finally, some students apparently equated bureaucracy with something else – e.g civil service, paperwork, neo-Confucianism, servomechanism – and wrote a critique of these without demonstrating a clear link to bureaucracy.

veryard projects - innovation for demanding change

Bureaucracy Quotes

veryard projects > business organization management > bureaucracy > quotes

“The conception of government as the machinery that guarantees the execution of the monarch’s utterance was now reshaped into one that prepares texts for the monarch’s signature. The state governed by the management of texts - that is, the modern bureaucratic state - was taking shape.” [Ivan Illich & Barry Sanders, ABC: The Alphabetization of the Popular Mind (Marion Boyers, 1988) Penguin ed pp 65-66]
more Lewis Mumford on Bureaucracy

veryard projects - innovation for demanding change

Sources of Material on Bureaucracy

veryard projects > business organization management > bureaucracy > sources

more BOLA : Business Open Learning Archive
About Psychology - Bureaucracy
Article: Bureaucracy as Idealization (Jon Bennett)
Book Comment Information
Penguin Dictionary of Sociology Useful introductory reference - to help you get your bearings if you haven't studied sociology before.
Derek Pugh (ed) Organization Theory (Penguin) Contains several classic papers on bureaucracy and related matters.
Gareth Morgan, Images of Organization (Sage) Reviews bureaucracy and other organizational forms and patterns, from several different aspects.
veryard projects - innovation for demanding change

[home page]

[contact us]

This page last updated on June 26th, 2003
Copyright © 2003 Veryard Projects Ltd